| 274615 | Card | Private Signing | 2016 Topps Heritage #264 Blue Sharpie INDIANS | | premium members only |
| 274616 | Card | Private Signing | 1982 Topps #118 **Triple signed card with Brad Mills and Bryn Smith** Francona and Smith in Blue Sharpie, Mills in Black Sharpie EXPOS | | premium members only |
| 381046 | Card | In Person | 1992 Fleer Procard South Bend White Sox black | | premium members only |
| 381047 | Card | In Person | 1992 Classic Best South Bend White Sox black | | premium members only |
| 395600 | Card | Bought | 2001 Topps Phillies blue | | premium members only |
| 215208 | Card | Bought | 1986 Topps Terry Francona in black sharpie |  | premium members only |
| 228637 | Card | In Person | 2014 topps heritage signed in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 269351 | Card | Private Signing | 1988 Score | | premium members only |
| 269352 | Card | Private Signing | 2017 Topps MOY Insert | | premium members only |
| 292356 | Card | In Person | 83 Donruss in black sharpie | | premium members only |
| 382432 | Card | Bought | 1983 Fleer #281
Thin black sharpie | | premium members only |
| 384013 | Card | Bought | 1987 Fleer #564
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 190444 | Card | In Person | 2014 TOPPS HERITAGE #301 INDIANS IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 190446 | Card | In Person | 1989 TOPPS #31 INDIANS IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 269515 | Card | By Mail | 1982 Topps # 118 Future Stars - signed by all three | | premium members only |
| 275493 | Index Card | By Mail | vintage fine tip marker | | premium members only |
| 124660 | Baseball | In Person | ROMLB [sweet spot in blue ballpoint] | | premium members only |
