| 328962 | Card | By Mail | 1991 Upper Deck All-Star #84F Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 264514 | Card | By Mail | 1984 Fleer #392 | | premium members only |
| 85696 | Card | By Mail | 1991 Upper Deck, Blue Sharpie, Boston Red Sox |  | premium members only |
| 85697 | Card | By Mail | 1991 Upper Deck Toronto All Star Game, Blue Sharpie, Boston Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 85699 | Card | By Mail | 2000 Topps Season Highlights, Blue Sharpie, Tampa Bay Devil Rays | | premium members only |
| 261082 | Card | By Mail | 2000 Fleer Ultra, blue sharpie, slightly smeared, Tampa Bay Rays, scan available upon request | | premium members only |
| 205810 | Card | By Mail | Donruss champions - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 164374 | Card | By Mail | 1987 TOPPS #150 RED SOX BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 373053 | Card | By Mail | 1983 TOPPS #498 RED SOX IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 373054 | Card | By Mail | 1983 DONRUSS #586 RED SOX IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 373055 | Card | By Mail | 1983 FLEER #179 RED SOX IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 193412 | Card | By Mail | 1997 Pawtucket Red Sox 25th Anniversary signed in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 250097 | Card | In Person | 1999 Upper Deck 10th Anniversary Team #X15, blue sharpie - Devil Rays | | premium members only |
| 250098 | Card | In Person | 2012 Topps Retired Numbers Patch #RN-WB, blue sharpie - Devil Rays | | premium members only |
| 251905 | Card | In Person | 1991 Topps #450, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 251906 | Card | In Person | 1992 Studio Heritage Series #BC3, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 251907 | Card | In Person | 1987 Topps #608, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 251908 | Card | In Person | 1990 Bowman #281, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 251909 | Card | In Person | 1988 Topps UK Minis #4, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 251910 | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Allen & Ginter Mini #181, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 193738 | Card | By Mail | Rookie Card | | premium members only |
| 222924 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps All-Star #608 Blue Sharpie RED SOX | | premium members only |
| 222927 | Card | By Mail | 1991 Donruss #178 Blue Sharpie RED SOX | | premium members only |
| 222928 | Card | By Mail | 2008 UD Baseball Heroes #34 Blue Sharpie RED SOX | | premium members only |
| 222929 | Card | By Mail | 1992 Pinnacle #175 Blue Sharpie RED SOX | | premium members only |
| 223352 | Card | By Mail | 1993 Leaf #285 Blue Sharpie YANKEES | | premium members only |
| 223353 | Card | By Mail | 1994 Score Select #156 Blue Sharpie YANKEES | | premium members only |
| 223354 | Card | By Mail | 1995 Topps #170 Blue Sharpie YANKEES | | premium members only |
| 390766 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Fleer Super Star Special w/Hernandez unsigned | | premium members only |
| 304765 | Card | In Person | 1998 Skybox Dugout Axcess #83 | | premium members only |
| 349690 | Card | By Mail | 1986 Topps | | premium members only |
| 289670 | Card | By Mail | 1986 Topps 510 blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 289672 | Card | By Mail | 1991 Topps 450 blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 289693 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Donruss 252 blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 289706 | Card | By Mail | 1989 Upper Deck 389 blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 336734 | Card | By Mail | 1989 Topps #600 (blue sharpie) Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 250376 | Card | By Mail | 1997 Score | | premium members only |
| 266305 | Card | Trade | 1987 Topps | | premium members only |
| 272968 | Card | By Mail | 2016 Topps Stadium Club | | premium members only |
| 274334 | Card | By Mail | 1988 Fleer | | premium members only |
| 274335 | Card | By Mail | 1993 Upper Deck | | premium members only |
| 336388 | Card | Bought | 1987 Topps Creased | | premium members only |
| 285490 | Card | By Mail | 2018 A&G Allen Ginter (2), 1996 fleer | | premium members only |
| 382850 | Card | By Mail | 1992 Upper Deck (Red Sox)- signed in blue | | premium members only |
| 382851 | Card | By Mail | 1998 Topps (Yankees)- signed in blue | | premium members only |
| 382852 | Card | By Mail | 1985 Donruss (Red Sox)- signed in blue | | premium members only |
| 333496 | Card | By Mail | 1984 Topps Batting Leaders signed with Bill Madlock | | premium members only |
| 375063 | Card | Bought | 1987 Topps #150 | | premium members only |
| 282428 | Card | By Mail | 1985 Topps | | premium members only |
| 282429 | Card | By Mail | 1986 Topps | | premium members only |
| 269868 | Card | Trade | 1989 Fleer #81 - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 291163 | Card | By Mail | 1983 Donruss #586 (Rookie card) - Red Sox (BAS Authenticated/Slabbed) | | premium members only |
| 292690 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps Wade Boggs in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 201897 | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps #150 | | premium members only |
| 130800 | Photo | In Person | Wade Boggs signed photo from an appearance at local casino | | premium members only |
