| Twardoski, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1992 Skybox Minors in black (Red Sox) | | premium members only |
| Kelly, Tom | BB | Card | By Mail | 1988 Topps in blue (Twins) | | premium members only |
| Kirkwood, Don | BB | Card | By Mail | 1978 Topps in blue (White Sox) | | premium members only |
| Kirkwood, Don | BB | Card | By Mail | 1979 Topps in blue (Blue Jays) | | premium members only |
| Lewis, Mark | BB | Card | By Mail | 1997 UD Collectors Choice in black (Giants) | | premium members only |
| Sanchez, Israel | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 Donruss in blue (Royals) | | premium members only |
| George, Chris (1991 Brewers) | BB | Card | By Mail | 1992 Upperdeck in blue (Brewers) | | premium members only |
| George, Chris (1991 Brewers) | BB | Card | By Mail | 1992 Donruss in blue (Brewers) | | premium members only |
| Lewis, Mark | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Bowman in black (Indians) | | premium members only |
| Searcy, Steve | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Fleer in blue (Tigers) | | premium members only |
| Searcy, Steve | BB | Card | By Mail | 1992 Topps in blue (Phillies) | | premium members only |
| Bailey, Roger | BB | Card | By Mail | 1996 Fleer in black (Rockies) | | premium members only |
| Almon, Bill | BB | Card | By Mail | 1983 Topps Traded in blue (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| Almon, Bill | BB | Card | By Mail | 1985 Topps in blue (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Phil | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 Upperdeck in blue (Phillies) | | premium members only |
| Bournigal, Rafael | BB | Card | By Mail | 1998 Mothers Cookies in black (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| Bournigal, Rafael | BB | Card | By Mail | 1997 Mothers Cookies in black (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| Bournigal, Rafael | BB | Card | By Mail | 1996 Mothers Cookies in black (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| Buchanan, Bob | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 CMC in blue (Royals) | | premium members only |
| Brown, Marty | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 Fleer in blue (Reds) | | premium members only |
| George, Chris (1991 Brewers) | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 ProCards in blue (Brewers) | | premium members only |
| Whitaker, Lou | BB | Card | By Mail | 1992 Topps #570
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| LaCoss, Mike | BB | Card | Bought | 87 Topps #151
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Leiper, Dave | BB | Card | By Mail | 87 Donruss #472
Thin blue marker | | premium members only |
| Dumatrait, Phil | BB | Card | By Mail | 2001 Topps Traded #T164
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Whitlock, Garrett | BB | Card | Bought | 2021 Topps Gallery #RA-GW
Pack pulled | | premium members only |
| Sierra, Candy | BB | Card | By Mail | 89 Topps #711
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Hentgen, Pat | BB | Card | Bought | 96 Topps #148
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Vaughn, Greg | BB | Card | By Mail | 92 Topps #572
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Gardner, Wes | BB | Card | By Mail | 88 Topps #189
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Hurst, Bruce | BB | Card | Bought | 90 UD #433
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Madlock, Bill | BB | Card | By Mail | 2024 Topps Living Set #779
Blue sharpie, with Mad Dog inscription | | premium members only |
| Darling, Ron | BB | Card | Bought | 90 Topps #330
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Magrane, Joe | BB | Card | Bought | 91 Studio #235
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Bordick, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1997 Topps #86 A’s | | premium members only |
| Bordick, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 2000 Topps #172 Orioles | | premium members only |
| Bordick, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 2003 Topps Total #28 Blue Jays | | premium members only |
Quisenberry, Dan  | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Fleer #259
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Bielecki, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Donruss DK #9
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Lever, Lafayette | BK | Card | By Mail | 1990 Hoops #97
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Toon, Al | FB | Card | By Mail | 91 Fleer #154
Black ballpoint | | premium members only |
| Drabek, Doug | BB | Card | By Mail | 90 UD #597
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Walton, Jerome | BB | Card | By Mail | 91 Fleer Ultra #70
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
Smith, Lee  | BB | Card | By Mail | 87T #23
Thin blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Burke, Tim | BB | Card | By Mail | 91 Fleer Ultra #198
Blue sharpie with religious inscription | | premium members only |
| Belcher, Tim | BB | Card | By Mail | 90UD #547
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Brunansky, Tom | BB | Card | By Mail | 84T #447
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Bolton, Tom | BB | Card | By Mail | 88T #442
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Rivers, Glenn "Doc" | BK | Card | Bought | 1992/93 Upper Deck #101
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Kile, Darryl | BB | Card | Bought | 1992 Topps #134
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Timlin, Mike | BB | Card | Bought | 1993 Topps #564
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Nipper, Al | BB | Card | Bought | 1987 Topps #617
Thin blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Darling, Ron | BB | Card | Bought | 1992 Upper Deck #669
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Sebra, Bob | BB | Card | Bought | 1988 Topps #93
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Berry, Quintin | BB | Card | Bought | 2006 Bowman #DP53
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Fernandez, Sid | BB | Card | Bought | 1991 Topps #230
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Darling, Ron | BB | Card | Bought | 1990 Donruss #289
Red sharpie | | premium members only |
| Williamson, Scott | BB | Card | Bought | 2005 Topps #234
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Newman, Al | BB | Card | Bought | 1990 Donruss #506
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Ojeda, Bob | BB | Card | Bought | 1986 Topps #11
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Johnson, John Henry | BB | Card | Bought | 1987 Topps #377
Thin blue marker | | premium members only |
| Stieb, Dave | BB | Card | Bought | 1988 Score #76
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Stillwell, Kurt | BB | Card | By Mail | 1991 Studio #70
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Reardon, Jeff | BB | Card | By Mail | 1992 Topps #3 Record Breaker
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Cliburn, Stan | BB | Card | By Mail | 1986 Topps #179
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Ozark, Danny | BB | Card | Bought | 1985 Topps #365
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Fontenot, Ray | BB | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps #124
Thin blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Kopech, Michael | BB | Card | Bought | 2017 Bowman #DP29
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Drohan, Shane | BB | Card | Bought | 2020 Bowman Draft #170
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Darling, Ron | BB | Card | Bought | 1994 Topps Traded #27
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Francona, Terry | BB | Card | Bought | 1983 Fleer #281
Thin black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Fernandez, Sid | BB | Card | Bought | 1986 Topps #104
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Miller, Wade | BB | Card | Bought | 2005 Topps #580
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Schiraldi, Calvin | BB | Card | Bought | 1990 Upper Deck #643
Black Sharpie | | premium members only |
| Backman, Wally | BB | Card | Bought | 1986 Topps #191
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Hermanson, Dustin | BB | Card | Bought | 2000 Topps #323
Thin black marker | | premium members only |
| Craig, Roger | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Topps #351
Black sharpie | | premium members only |
| Gwynn, Chris | BB | Card | Bought | 1992 Topps #604
Blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Johnson, Josh | BB | Card | Bought | 2006 Fleer | | premium members only |
| Adon, Joan | BB | Card | Bought | 2022 Topps Heritage #688 Nationals Rookie signed in thin blue | | premium members only |
| Kendrick, Howie | BB | Card | Trade | 2007 Upper Deck #135 Angels signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Wesneski, Hayden | BB | Card | Trade | 2019 Bomwan Draft #BD-177 Yankees 1st signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Ray, Robbie | BB | Card | By Mail | 2011 Topps Minor League Heritage #200 Nationals signed in black | | premium members only |
| Fillmyer, Heath | BB | Card | Trade | Autographed 2019 Topps trading card #326. (Kansas City Royals) | | premium members only |
| Dozier, Hunter | BB | Card | Trade | Autographed 2014 Bowman trading card #BP51. (Kansas City Royals) | | premium members only |
| Cook, Steve | OT | Card | Trade | Autographed 1990 Collection-A-Card Kingpin trading card #36. | | premium members only |
| Clukey, Julia | OT | Card | Trade | Autographed 2014 Topps U.S. Olympic Team trading card #16. | | premium members only |
| Camarillo, Rich | FB | Card | By Mail | Autographed 1995 Topps Stadium Club trading card #28. (Houston Oilers) | | premium members only |
| Camarillo, Rich | FB | Card | By Mail | Autographed 1992 NFL Pro Set trading card #289. (Phoenix Cardinals) | | premium members only |
| Camarillo, Rich | FB | Card | By Mail | Autographed 1990 Topps trading card #436. (Phoenix Cardinals) | | premium members only |
| Camarillo, Rich | FB | Card | By Mail | Autographed 1992 Upper Deck trading card #521. (Phoenix Cardinals) | | premium members only |
| Maynard, Gray | OT | Card | Bought | 2010 Topps UFC #24 signed in silver | | premium members only |
| Emmett, Josh | OT | Card | By Mail | 2021 Panini Prizm UFC #121 signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Xiaonan, Yan | OT | Card | By Mail | 2022 Panini Prizm UFC #194 signed in thin blue | | premium members only |
| Ward, Micky | OT | Card | In Person | 2018 Sport Kings #41 “The Fighter” inscription signed in black | | premium members only |
| Ellis, Leron | BK | Card | Bought | 1992 Wild Card #2 Syracuse signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Niederreiter, Nino | HK | Card | Bought | 2011 Panini Score Rookies and Traded #568 Islanders signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Johnson, Nick | HK | Card | Bought | 2012-13 Panini Score #242 Coyotes signed in blue | | premium members only |
| McNabb, Brayden | HK | Card | Bought | 2009 In The Game CHL #122 Ice signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Comrie, Eric | HK | Card | Bought | 2012 In The Game CHL #96 Rookie Americans signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Kostka, Mike | HK | Card | Bought | 2013-14 Panini Score #628 Rookie Maple Leafs signed in silver | | premium members only |
| Koekkoek, Slater | HK | Card | Bought | 2014-15 Upper Deck AHL hockey #27 Crunch signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Desjardins, Cedrick | HK | Card | Bought | 2011 Panini Rookies & Traded Rookie Lightning signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Butler, Raymond | FB | Card | By Mail | Autographed 1985 Topps trading card #259. (Baltimore Colts) | | premium members only |
| Melvin, Rashaan | FB | Photo | In Person | 8x10 photo - thin stock - Indianapolis Colts |  | premium members only |
| Doyle, Jack | FB | Photo | In Person | 8x10 photo - Indianapolis Colts | | premium members only |
| Ebron, Eric | FB | Photo | In Person | 8x10 photo - Indianapolis Colts | | premium members only |
| Franklin, Zaire | FB | Photo | In Person | 8x10 photo - Indianapolis Colts | | premium members only |
| Arrington, J.J. | FB | Card - Certified | Trade | 2006 Topps - Autographs - Certified - Arizona Cardinals #T-JAR | | premium members only |
| Farley, Matthias | FB | Photo | In Person | 8x10 photo - thin stock - Indianapolis Colts | | premium members only |
| Gayle, Shaun | FB | Card | Trade | 1991 Pacific - Chicago Bears | | premium members only |
| Anderson, Neal | FB | Card | Trade | 1991 Pacific - Chicago Bears | | premium members only |
| Shelton, Danny | FB | Card - Certified | Trade | 2015 Bowman - Chrome Rookie Autographs - Refractor - Washington Huskies - Cleveland Browns | | premium members only |
| Rader, Doug | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Topps - California Angels | | premium members only |
| Renko, Steve | BB | Card | By Mail | 1975 Topps - Montreal Expos | | premium members only |
| Kennedy, Terry | BB | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps - San Diego Padres | | premium members only |
| Dunning, Steve | BB | Card | By Mail | 1973 Topps - Cleveland Indians
| | premium members only |
| Cullen, Tim | BB | Card | By Mail | 1970 Topps - Washington Senators
| | premium members only |
| Morris, Jack | BB | Card | Bought | 1987 Topps #778 Blue Sharpie TIGERS | | premium members only |
| Quinones, Rey | BB | Card | By Mail | 1988 Fleer #386 Blue Sharpie MARINERS | | premium members only |
| Quinones, Rey | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 Score #361 Blue Sharpie MARINERS | | premium members only |
| Adduci, Jim (1983-89) | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 Fleer #176 Blue Sharpie BREWERS | | premium members only |
| Laga, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 Score - blue | | premium members only |
| Laga, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1986 Donruss - blue | | premium members only |
| Kennedy, Terry | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Fleer - blue | | premium members only |
| Washington, Ted (1991-2006) | FB | Photo | By Mail | Buffalo Bills - 8x10 | | premium members only |
| Washington, Ted (1991-2006) | FB | Card | By Mail | 1991 Proline RC - 49ers | | premium members only |
| Hough, Charlie | BB | Card | By Mail | 1991 Upper Deck #313 Rangers | | premium members only |
| Hough, Charlie | BB | Card | By Mail | 1991 Upper Deck #313 Rangers | | premium members only |
| Hough, Charlie | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Donruss #411 Rangers | | premium members only |
| Hough, Charlie | BB | Card | By Mail | 1988 Topps #680 Rangers | | premium members only |
| Pearson, Drew | FB | Card | Bought | Acquired this as part of a package deal for Ozzie Smith. I do not collect football, so looking to trade this for just about any St. Louis Cardinals (baseball) color 8x10. If you have any interest, and something to offer, shoot me a message! | | premium members only |
| Wood, Leonard | OT | Card | By Mail | maxx 92 43-50 signed by len, leonard and eddie | | premium members only |
| Brownlie, Bobby | BB | Card | In Person | 2004 Southern League Top Prospects (Blue Sharpie Little Faded) | | premium members only |
| Brownlie, Bobby | BB | Card | In Person | 2004 Bowman 1st Year 167 (Blue Staedtler) Cubs | | premium members only |
| Broxton, Keon | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps Pro Debut 88 (Blue Sharpie) South Bend | | premium members only |
| Broxton, Keon | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Pro Debut 98 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Rawhide | | premium members only |
| Broxton, Keon | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Topps Series #2 Rookie Card 364 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Brewers | | premium members only |
| Broxton, Keon | BB | Card | In Person | 2018 Topps Series #1 61 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Brewers | | premium members only |
| Broxton, Keon | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP42 (Blue Sharpie) Diamondbacks | | premium members only |
| Brown, Mitch | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Pro Debut 214 (Blue Sharpie) AZL Indians | | premium members only |
| Brown, Mitch | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Heritage Minor League 15 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Lake County | | premium members only |
| Brown, Jordan | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Tristar Pursuit For The Record 49 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Brown, Jordan | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Tristar Projections 170 (Blue Sharpie) Aeros | | premium members only |
| Brown, Jordan | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Bowman Draft Picks Rookie Card BDP72 (Blue Sharpie) Indians 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Brown, Dermal | BB | Card | In Person | 1999 Upper Deck Star Rookie 22 (Blue Sharpie) Royals | | premium members only |
| Brown, Corey | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Tristar Prospect Plus Pro Debut 23 (Blue Sharpie) Vancouver | | premium members only |
| Brown, Corey | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Tristar Projections 72 (Blue Sharpie) Canadians | | premium members only |
| Brown, Corey | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP3 (Blue Sharpie) A's | | premium members only |
| Brown, Brant | BB | Card | In Person | 1993 Upper Deck Minor League Top Prospect 134 (Blue Sharpie) Cubs | | premium members only |
| Brown, Andrew (2006 Indians) | BB | Card | In Person | 2004 Southern League Top Prospect (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Suns | | premium members only |
| Brown, Andrew (2006 Indians) | BB | Card | In Person | 2003 Donruss Rated Rookie 8 (Blue Sharpie) Dodgers | | premium members only |
| Brown, Adrian | BB | Card | In Person | 2001 Bowman 187 (Blue Sharpie) Pirates | | premium members only |
| Timmermann, Tom | BB | Card | By Mail | 1973 Topps - Detroit Tigers | | premium members only |
| Griffin, John-Ford | BB | Card | Bought | 2006 Fleer | | premium members only |
| Grubb, Johnny | BB | Card | By Mail | 1988 Score #199 Tigers | | premium members only |
| Fielder, Cecil | BB | Card | By Mail | 2013 A&G signed by mail for $10 fee. I got this one done by mistake. | | premium members only |
| Valentin, John | BB | Card | By Mail | 1997 Fleer #31 Red Sox | | premium members only |
| Valentin, John | BB | Card | By Mail | 2000 Topps #135 Red Sox | | premium members only |
| Valentin, John | BB | Card | By Mail | 1993 Stadium Club #508 Red Sox | | premium members only |
| Brosius, Tyler | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects BDPP101 (Blue Sharpie) Braves | | premium members only |
| Brooks, Aaron | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP55 (Blue Sharpie) Royals 3 Available | | premium members only |
| Brooks, Aaron | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP176 (Blue Sharpie) Royals | | premium members only |
| Broderick, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps 368 (Blue Sharpie) Nationals | | premium members only |
| Broderick, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Prospects BP75 (Blue Staedtler) Cardinals | | premium members only |
| Broderick, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP75 (Blue Sharpie) Cardinals | | premium members only |
| Broderick, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Applachian League Top Prosect (Blue Sharpie) Johnson City | | premium members only |
| Broberg, Pete | BB | Card | Trade | 1977 Topps 409 (Black Sharpie) Mariners | | premium members only |
| Broadway, Larry | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Upper Deck Future Gems 37 (Blue Staedtler) Expos | | premium members only |
| Broadway, Larry | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Pacific Coast League Top Prospects 15 of 34 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Broadway, Larry | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 New Orleans Zephyrs Team Card 3 of 36 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Broadway, Larry | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Pacific Coast League Top Prospects 8 of 36 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Broadway, Larry | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 New Orleans Zephyrs Team Card 4 of 36 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Brito, Socrates | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP62 (Blue Sharpie) 4 Available Diamondbacks | | premium members only |
| Brito, Socrates | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP62 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Diamondbacks | | premium members only |
| Brisker, Markus | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects BDPP20 (Blue Sharpie) Blue Jays | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Topps Pro Debut 43 (Blue Sharpie) Express | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Topps Pro Debut 52 (Blue Sharpie) Hickory | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Pro Debut 118 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available AZL Rangers | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Pro Debut 118 (Black Sharpie) AZL Rangers | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Heritage Minor League 114 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Hickory | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2018 Topps Fire Rookie 84 (Blue Sharpie) Brewers | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Platinum Prospects Rookie BPP3 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Rangers | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Bowman Top Prospect TP-53 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Rangers | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP137 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Rangers | | premium members only |
| Brinson, Lewis | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP31 (Blue Sharpie) Rangers | | premium members only |
| Brinkley, Darryl | BB | Card | In Person | 1999 Nashville Sounds Team Card (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Brill, Matt | BB | Card | In Person | 2019 Visallia Rawhide Team Card (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Brignac, Reid | BB | Card | Trade | 2009 Topps 296 (Blue Sharpie) Rays | | premium members only |
| Brignac, Reid | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Southern League Top Prospect (Blue Sharpie) Montgomery | | premium members only |
| Brignac, Reid | BB | Card | Trade | 2008 International League Top Prospect 04 (Blue Sharpie Streaky) Durham | | premium members only |
| Brigman, Bryson | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Bowman Chrome Draft BDC-105 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Mariners | | premium members only |
| Brigman, Bryson | BB | Card | Trade | 2011 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects USA Baseball BDDP93 (Black Ink Pen) | | premium members only |
| Brigman, Bryson | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps USA Baseball USA USA-25 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Brigman, Bryson | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 USA Baseball Panini Champions 18U 153 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Brigman, Bryson | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Bowman Draft BDC-105 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Mariners | | premium members only |
| Brigham, Jeff | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Bowman Draft Picks DP66 (Blue Sharpie) 7 Available Dodgers | | premium members only |
| Brigham, Jeff | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks 1st Year Card CDP66 (Blue Sharpie) Dodgers | | premium members only |
| Brigham, Jake | BB | Card | In Person | 2009 Hickory Crawdads Team Card (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Brigham, Jake | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Tristar Projections Gray/Mirror Version 65 (Blue Sharpie) Indians | | premium members only |
| Brigham, Jake | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Tristar Projections 65 (Blue Sharpie) Spokane | | premium members only |
| Bridwell, Parker | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition 94 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Brickhouse, Bryan | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP84 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Royals | | premium members only |
| Brice, Austin | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP170 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Marlins | | premium members only |
| Brewer, Jace | BB | Card | In Person | 2000 Fleer Tradition Update U149 (Blue Staedtler) Rays | | premium members only |
| Rivera, Saul | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Topps 52 in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Barrett, Aaron | BB | Card | In Person | 2020 Topps in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| De Los Santos, Abel | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Topps in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Anderson, Marlon | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Upperdeck in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Reynolds, Mark | BB | Card | Private Signing | 2018 Topps Big League in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Severino, Pedro | BB | Card | In Person | 2018 Topps Heritage in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Schaefer, Jeff | BB | Card | By Mail | 1991 Topps in blue (Mariners) | | premium members only |
| Schaefer, Jeff | BB | Card | By Mail | 1991 Fleer Update in blue (Mariners) | | premium members only |
| Kingery, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Donruss in blue (Mariners) | | premium members only |
| Kingery, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1988 Donruss in blue (Mariners) | | premium members only |
| Schmidt, Dave (1981-92) | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Donruss in blue (Orioles) | | premium members only |
| Chick, Travis | BB | Card | By Mail | 2007 Topps Heritage in blue (Mariners) | | premium members only |
| Chambers, Travis | BB | Card | By Mail | 1987 TCMA in black | | premium members only |
| Chambers, Travis | BB | Card | By Mail | 1989 ProCards in black (Expos) | | premium members only |
| Paul, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1973 Topps in blue (Rangers) | | premium members only |
| Stein, Blake | BB | Card | By Mail | 2001 Bowman Heritage in black (Royals) | | premium members only |
| Aguayo, Luis | BB | Card | Bought | 1987 Topps #755 Black Sharpie PHILLIES | | premium members only |
| Aguayo, Luis | BB | Card | Trade | 1983 Topps #252 Black Sharpie PHILLIES | | premium members only |
| Aguayo, Luis | BB | Card | Trade | 1982 Topps #449 Blue Sharpie PHILLIES | | premium members only |
| DiGiorgio, John | FB | Card | By Mail | 2008 Score - Buffalo Bills | | premium members only |
| Cobb, Marvin | FB | Card | By Mail | 77 Topps #52 Bengals (blue sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Washington, U.L. | BB | Card | Bought | 1981 Fleer - blue | | premium members only |
| Motley, Darryl | BB | Card | By Mail | 1982 Donruss - ink | | premium members only |
| Dirks, Andy | BB | Card | By Mail | 13 Topps #630 Tigers (blue sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Dirks, Andy | BB | Card | By Mail | 12 Topps #644 Tigers (blue sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Brewer, Charles | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Topps 100 TP51 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Diamondbacks | | premium members only |
| Brewer, Charles | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects BCP12 (Blue Sharpie) Diamondbacks | | premium members only |
| Brett, Ryan | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Topps Heritage Minor League 30 (Blue Sharpie) Bowling Green | | premium members only |
| Brett, Ryan | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowling Green Hot Rods Team Set (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Brett, Ryan | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps Pro Debut 278 (Blue Sharpie) GCL Rays | | premium members only |
| Brett, Ryan | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP5 (Blue Sharpie) Rays | | premium members only |
| Brennan, Brandon | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP102 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available White Sox | | premium members only |
| Benedict, Bruce | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Topps #583 Braves | | premium members only |
| Benedict, Bruce | BB | Card | By Mail | 1988 Topps #652 Braves | | premium members only |
| Hogan, Hulk | OT | Magazine | In Person | Sports Illustrated 4/29/85 | | premium members only |
| Norrick, Tyler | BB | Card | Bought | 2006 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks #DP42, blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Huff, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | 1992 Pinnacle While Sox blue | | premium members only |
| Hughes, Jared | BB | Card | Bought | 2012 Topps Heritage - blue sharpie PIRATES | | premium members only |
| Mathisen, Wyatt | BB | Card | Bought | 2013 Bowman Prospects #BP87 - Blue Sharpie | | premium members only |
| McClure, Kade | BB | Card | Bought | 2017 Bowman Draft (BD-173) in blue | | premium members only |
| Molina, Bengie | BB | Card | Bought | 2007 Bowman Heritage Giants blue | | premium members only |
| Molina, Bengie | BB | Card | Bought | 2006 Bowman Heritage Bluejays blue | | premium members only |
| Moore, Tyler | BB | Card | Bought | 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects #BCP138, blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Moore, Tyler | BB | Card | Bought | 2012 TOPPS UPDATE #US208 RC NATIONALS IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| Elledge, Seth | BB | Card | Bought | '17 Bowman Draft #BD-3 Seattle Mariners signed in blue | | premium members only |
| Marshall, Mac | BB | Card | Bought | 2015 Bowman Draft Picks #113, blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Mitchell, Bryan | BB | Card | Bought | 2015 Bowman Yankees blue | | premium members only |
| Hunt, Blake | BB | Card | Bought | 2017 Bowman #bd145 in blue Padres | | premium members only |
| Jones, Thomas | BB | Card | Bought | 2016 Bowman Draft #BD-2 Marlins blue | | premium members only |
| Lakins, Travis | BB | Card | Bought | 2018 Bowman #BP139 Red Sox signed in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Mitchell, Bryan | BB | Card | By Mail | 2015 Panini DK Yankees blue | | premium members only |
| Corcino, Daniel | BB | Card | Trade | 2012 Topps Heritage Minors black | | premium members only |
| Gray, Jon | BB | Card | Bought | 2014
Bowman Rockies blue | | premium members only |
| Gray, Jon | BB | Card | Bought | 2018
Topps Heritage Rockies blue | | premium members only |
| Gray, Jon | BB | Card | Bought | 2017
Topps Rockies blue | | premium members only |
| Gray, Jon | BB | Card | Bought | 2019 Topps Rockies blue | | premium members only |
| Gray, Jon | BB | Card | Bought | 2020 Topps Rockies blue | | premium members only |
| Callihan, Tyler | BB | Card | Bought | 2020 Bowman Reds blue | | premium members only |
| Callihan, Tyler | BB | Card | Bought | 2021 Topps Heritage Minors blue | | premium members only |
| Hooker, Deryk | BB | Card | Bought | 2011 Bowman Prospects #BP40, blue sharpie Cardinals | | premium members only |
| Jenkins, Tyrell | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Bowman Draft Cardinals blue | | premium members only |
| Jenkins, Tyrell | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps Heritage Minors blue | | premium members only |
| Joaquin, Waldis | BB | Card | By Mail | 2008 Bowman Chrome Giants Blue | | premium members only |
| Jones, Daryl | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Just Minors Justifiable JF-17 (Blue Sharpie) Cardinals | | premium members only |
| Joseph, Donnie | BB | Card | By Mail | 2010 Elite Extra Edition blue | | premium members only |
| Hunter, Cedric | BB | Card | Bought | 2011 Topps Padres blue | | premium members only |
| Hutchison, Drew | BB | Card | By Mail | 2015 Topps Heritage Bluejays blue | | premium members only |
| Hutton, Mark | BB | Card | Bought | 1997 Fleer Marlins blue | | premium members only |
| Hutton, Tommy | BB | Card | By Mail | 1981 Topps Expos blue | | premium members only |
| Ilsley, Blaise | BB | Card | Bought | 1995 Score Cubs blue | | premium members only |
| Ilsley, Blaise | BB | Card | Bought | 1994 Ultra Cubs blue | | premium members only |
| Ilsley, Blaise | BB | Card | Bought | 1991 Line Drive AAA blue | | premium members only |
| Jackson, Darrin | BB | Card | Bought | 1991 Topps Padres blue | | premium members only |
| Jacoby, Brook | BB | Card | Bought | 1988 Topps Indians blue | | premium members only |
| Moore, Scott | BB | Card | Bought | 2008 Topps Orioles blue | | premium members only |
| Murphy, Tom (2015 Rockies) | BB | Card | Bought | 2015 Panini Diamond Kings Rockies blue | | premium members only |
| Navarro, Jaime | BB | Card | Bought | 1992 Topps Brewers blue | | premium members only |
| Nagy, Charles | BB | Card | Bought | 1995 Topps Indians blue | | premium members only |
| Nagy, Charles | BB | Card | Bought | 1993 Topps Indians blue | | premium members only |
| Nagy, Charles | BB | Card | Bought | 1991 Topps Indians blue | | premium members only |
| Nagy, Charles | BB | Card | Bought | 1992 Topps Indians blue | | premium members only |
| Navarro, Yamaico | BB | Card | Bought | 2008 Tristar Projections | | premium members only |
| Nicolino, Justin | BB | Card | By Mail | 2014 Bowman Platinum Marlins blue | | premium members only |
| Nieves, Wil | BB | Card | Bought | 2010 Upper Deck Nationals blue | | premium members only |
| Eberwein, Kevin | BB | Card | In Person | 1999 Bowman Padres blue | | premium members only |
| Davis, J.D. | BB | Card | In Person | 2018 Topps Astros blue | | premium members only |
| Davidson, Tucker | BB | Card | In Person | 2021 Panini Diamond Kings blue braves | | premium members only |
| Davidson, Tucker | BB | Card | In Person | 2021 Panini Prizm blue braves | | premium members only |
| Cooper, Garrett | BB | Card | In Person | 2022 Topps Marlins blue | | premium members only |
| Burr, Ryan | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Topps USA blue | | premium members only |
| Burr, Ryan | BB | Card | In Person | 2015 Panini Contenders blue | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Scott | BB | Card | In Person | 1991 Stadium Club Mariners blue | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Scott | BB | Card | In Person | 1989 Topps Mariners blue | | premium members only |
| Bolt, Skye | BB | Card | In Person | 2019 Topps Update A's blue | | premium members only |
| Beeks, Jalen | BB | Card | In Person | 2019 Topps Gallery Rays blue | | premium members only |
| Beeks, Jalen | BB | Card | In Person | 2019 Topps Gypsy Queen Rays blue | | premium members only |
| Andriese, Matt | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Topps Rays blue | | premium members only |
| Houser, Adrian | BB | Card | In Person | 2022 Topps Brewers blue | | premium members only |
| Holmes, Grant | BB | Card | In Person | 2015 Bowman A's blue | | premium members only |
| Zamora, Freddy | BB | Card | In Person | 2021 Bowman BP-2 Brewers blue | | premium members only |
| Wilson, Jack | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Upper Deck Goudey Pirates blue | | premium members only |
| Wilson, Jack | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Topps Gallery Pirates blue | | premium members only |
| Wilson, Jack | BB | Card | In Person | 2004 Topps Heritage Pirates blue | | premium members only |
| Wilson, Jack | BB | Card | In Person | 2003 Donruss Pirates blue | | premium members only |
| Widener, Taylor | BB | Card | In Person | 2022 Topps blue | | premium members only |
| White, Mitch | BB | Card | In Person | 2018 Bowman Dodgers blue | | premium members only |
| Wasdin, John | BB | Card | In Person | 1997 Topps A's blue | | premium members only |
| Wasdin, John | BB | Card | In Person | 1998 MLB Showdown Red Sox blue | | premium members only |
| Wall, Forrest | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Panini Elite 5 blue | | premium members only |
| Wall, Forrest | BB | Card | In Person | 16 Topps Heritage Minor League | | premium members only |
| Speas, Alex | BB | Card | Bought | 2017 Bowman Prospects #68-Rangers-blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| Riske, David | BB | Card | Bought | 2007 Topps Heritage Indians blue | | premium members only |
| Riske, David | BB | Card | Bought | 2009 Upper Deck Brewers blue | | premium members only |
| Ray, Corey | BB | Card | Bought | 2019 Topps Heritage Minors blue | | premium members only |
| Prieto, Cesar | BB | Card | Bought | 2022 Bowman Chrome Draft Orioles blue | | premium members only |
| Brenly, Michael | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Prospects BP15 (Blue Staedtler) Cubs | | premium members only |
| Brenly, Michael | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Chrome Prospects BCP15 (1 Blue Sharpie & 1 Blue Staedtler) Cubs | | premium members only |
| Braun, Ryan (Brewers) | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Bowman FG3 (Blue Staedtler) 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Brattvet, Scott | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Donruss Elite Extra Edition 48 (Blue Sharpie) 4 Available | | premium members only |
| Branyan, Russell | BB | Card | In Person | 2001 Bowman 154 (Blue Staedtler) Indians | | premium members only |
| Rayford, Floyd | BB | Card | By Mail | 1983 topps orioles | | premium members only |
| Brantly, Rob | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition 60 (Blue Sharpie) UC Riverside | | premium members only |
| Brantley, Jeff | BB | Card | In Person | 1992 Topps 491 (Blue Sharpie) Giants | | premium members only |
| Branson, Jeff | BB | Card | Trade | 1988 Topps Traded 19T (Blue Pen) USA | | premium members only |
| Bragg, Darren | BB | Card | Trade | 1995 Upper Deck Star Rookie 238 (Black Sharpie) Mariners | | premium members only |
| Bragg, Darren | BB | Card | Trade | 1993 Upper Deck Minors 53 (Blue Sharpie) Suns | | premium members only |
| Brady, Sean | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Upper Deck USA 16U National Team Box Set USA-47 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available | | premium members only |
| Brady, Sean | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP93 (Blue Sharpie) USA | | premium members only |
| Brady, Michael (Marlins) | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP36 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Marlins | | premium members only |
| Brady, Michael (Marlins) | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP36 (Blue Sharpie) Marlins | | premium members only |
| Bradshaw, Terry | BB | Card | In Person | 1995 Bowman 71 (Blue Staedtler) Cardinals | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Phil | BB | Card | By Mail | 1986 Topps 305 (Black Pen) Marniers | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Phil | BB | Card | By Mail | 1990 Bowman 261 (Black Pen) Orioles | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Jed | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Heritage Minor League 38 (Blue Sharpie) 5 Available Brevard County | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Jed | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Topps Heritage Minor League 130 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Bevard County | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Jed | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Brevard County Manatees (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Bradley, J.R. | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps Pro Debut 7 (Blue Sharpie) Missoula | | premium members only |
| Bradley, J.R. | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition 9 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Bradley, J.R. | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP12 (Blue Sharpie) Diamondbacks 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Bradley, J.R. | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects BDPP12 (Blue Sharpie) Diamondbacks 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Bobby (2019 Indians) | BB | Card | In Person | 2015 Bowman Draft Picks 1st Year Card DP86 (Blue Sharpie) 4 Available Indians | | premium members only |
| Bradley, Archie | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Playoff Contenders Prospect Ticket RT15 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Brackman, Andrew | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Upper Deck USA National Set 20 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Boyd, Jayce | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Panini Prizm Pereninnial Draft Picks No.29 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Boyd, Hudson | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects BDPP13 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Twins | | premium members only |
| Boyd, Hudson | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects BDPP13 (Blue Sharpie) Twins | | premium members only |
| Boyd, B.J. | BB | Card | In Person | 2018 Nashville Sounds Team Card 12 of 36 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Boyd, B.J. | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Bowman Chrome Prospects BCP203 (Blue Sharpie) A’s | | premium members only |
| Bowman, Shawn | BB | Card | In Person | 2009 Bowman Draft Picks World Baseball Classic BDPW28 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Bowman, Shawn | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Bowman 1st Year Card 287 (Blue Sharpie) Mets | | premium members only |
| Bowman, Matt | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP72 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Mets | | premium members only |
| Bowman, Drew | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP38 (Black Sharpie) Reds | | premium members only |
| Hudson, Orlando | BB | Card | Bought | I have a stack of the 2008 Allen & GInter's South Carolina insert cards signed. | | premium members only |
| Warner, Curt | FB | Card | In Person | Autographed 1990 NFL Pro Set trading card #555. (Los Angeles Rams) | | premium members only |
| Schlesinger, Rafe | BB | Card | By Mail | 2024 Bowman Draft. I obtained this card thru TTM. He sent me an extra card with the original card I sent. | | premium members only |
| Bowie, Micah | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 New Orleans Zephyrs Team Set 1 of 36 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Bowie, Micah | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Sacramento Rivercats Team Set 7 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Bowie, Micah | BB | Card | In Person | 2000 Skybox Dominion Prospect 253 (Blue Staedtler) Cubs | | premium members only |
| Bowden, Michael | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Tristar Projections 46 (Blue Sharpie) Jethawks | | premium members only |
| Bowden, Ben | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Bowman Draft BD-36 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Rockies | | premium members only |
| Botts, Jason | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Pacific Coast League Top Prospects 7 of 36 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Botts, Jason | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Oklahoma Redhawks Team Card 2 of 30 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Botts, Jason | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Topps 206 272 (Blue Staedtler) Rangers | | premium members only |
| Botts, Jason | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Topps Total 175 (Blue Staedtler) Rangers | | premium members only |
| Botts, Jason | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Topps Heritage 307 (Blue Staedtler) Rangers | | premium members only |
| Botts, Jason | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Topps Prospects 682 (Blue Sharpie) Rangers | | premium members only |
| Bott, Glenn | BB | Card | In Person | 2004 Jacksonville Suns Team Card (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Botelho, Derek | BB | Card | In Person | 2009 Gwinnett Braves Team Card 05 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Bostick, Chris | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Bowman Prospects BP140 (Blue Sharpie) Nationals | | premium members only |
| Bollo, Greg | BB | Card | By Mail | 66T...White Sox uni | | premium members only |
| Bosio, Chris | BB | Card | In Person | 1992 Leaf Series #2 266 (Blue Sharpie) Brewers | | premium members only |
| Bosio, Chris | BB | Card | In Person | 1991 Fleer 576 (Blue Sharpie) Brewers | | premium members only |
| Bosio, Chris | BB | Card | In Person | 1989 Fleer 179 (Blue Sharpie) Brewers | | premium members only |
| Bosio, Chris | BB | Card | In Person | 1994 Upper Deck SP 103 (Blus Sharpie) Brewers | | premium members only |
| Bosio, Chris | BB | Card | In Person | 1992 Donruss 471 (Blue Sharpie) Brewers | | premium members only |
| Bortnick, Tyler | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP18 (Blue Sharpie) Rays | | premium members only |
| Borenstein, Zach | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP10 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available D-Backs | | premium members only |
| Borenstein, Zach | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP10 (Blue Sharpie) Angels | | premium members only |
| Bordonaro, Mark | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Pro Debut 179 (Black Sharpie) Aquasox | | premium members only |
| Borders, Pat | BB | Card | In Person | 1994 Pinnacle 477 (Blue Sharpie) Blue Jays | | premium members only |
| Borden, Buddy | BB | Card | In Person | 2015 Topps Heritage Minor League 68 (Blue Sharpie) West Virginia | | premium members only |
| Borchering, Bobby | BB | Card | In Person | 2009 Donruss Elite Extra Edition 1 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Borchard, Joe | BB | Card | In Person | 2004 Upper Deck 25th USA Set USA-21 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Williams, Dick | BB | Index Card | In Person | (4) 3 BULE SHARPIE 1 BLUE INK YANKEES MARINERS REDSOX | | premium members only |
| Willis, Jim | BB | Index Card | By Mail | (2)BLACK SHARPIE "53-54 CUBS" | | premium members only |
| Westlake, Wally | BB | Index Card | By Mail | (3) BLACK INK 1"1954 iNDIANS" | | premium members only |
| Weis, Al | BB | Index Card | By Mail | BLUE INK "69 METS WORLD CHAMPS 1969" | | premium members only |
| Thormodsgard, Paul | BB | Index Card | By Mail | BLUE SHARPIE TWINS
| | premium members only |
| Wenz, Fred | BB | Index Card | By Mail | BLACK SHARPIE PHILLIES | | premium members only |
| Umbach, Arnie | BB | Index Card | By Mail | BLUE SHARPIE BRAVES | | premium members only |
| Travis, Cecil | BB | Index Card | By Mail | (3) blue ink (1) "WASH. senators 1933-1947" | | premium members only |
| Stock, Wes | BB | Index Card | By Mail | bLUE SHARPIE "BEST rEGARDS ATHLETICS | | premium members only |
| Starrette, Herman | BB | Index Card | By Mail | blue sharpie ORIOLES REDSOX PHILLIES BRAVES | | premium members only |
| Powers, Mike | BB | Card | By Mail | E.f. Mike powers indians | | premium members only |
| Pagan, Dave | BB | Index Card | By Mail | black sharpie yankees mariners | | premium members only |
| Borbon, Julio | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 USA Baseball National Team 3 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Borbon, Julio | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Upper Deck USA National Set 26 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Borbon, Julio | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Tristar Projections 232 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Spokane | | premium members only |
| Borbon, Julio | BB | Card | In Person | 2007 Tristar Prospect Plus 72 (Blue Sharpie) Rangers 2 Available | | premium members only |
| Borbon, Julio | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Card Gold BDPP26 (Blue Staedtler) Rangers | | premium members only |
| Bonser, Boof | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Topps Prospect 317 (Blue Sharpie) Giants | | premium members only |
| Bonser, Boof | BB | Card | In Person | 2003 Topps Traded Prospect T140 (Blue Sharpie) Giants | | premium members only |
| Bonilla, Lisalverto | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Pro Debut 145 (Blue Sharpie) Reading | | premium members only |
| Bonifacio, Jorge | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Heritage Minor League Rookie 177 (Blue Sharpie) Wilmington | | premium members only |
| Smith, Will (2019 Dodgers) | BB | Card | By Mail | 2016 Bowman Dodgers | | premium members only |
| Pederson, Joc | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman 2012 | | premium members only |
| Buehler, Walker | BB | Card | By Mail | 2015 Bowman Dodgers | | premium members only |
| Montgomery, Bob | BB | Index Card | By Mail | BLUE INK REDSOX | | premium members only |
| Newhauser, Don | BB | Card | By Mail | BLACK SHARPIE REDSOX | | premium members only |
| Morgan, Bobby | BB | Card | By Mail | BLUE INK BROOKLYN DODGERS | | premium members only |
| Marshall, Willard | BB | Card | By Mail | BLACK SHARPIE GIANTS | | premium members only |
| Malkmus, Bobby | BB | Card | By Mail | (2) BLUE SHARPIE "3:16" BROOKLYN DODGERS | | premium members only |
| Lopez, Hector | BB | Index Card | By Mail | BLUE SHARPIE YANKEES | | premium members only |
| Kipp, Fred | BB | Card | By Mail | BLUE INK YANKEES | | premium members only |
| Johnson, Dave (1974-78) | BB | Card | By Mail | BLUE SHARPIE "77-78 TWINS" | | premium members only |
| Hooten, Leon | BB | Index Card | By Mail | INDEX CARD BLUE SHARPIE "1974 OAKLAND A'S" | | premium members only |
| Hriniak, Walt | BB | Card | By Mail | INDEX CARD BLACK INK BRAVES PADRES REDSOX EXPOS | | premium members only |
| Hayworth, Red | BB | Card | By Mail | BLUE SHARPIE "BEST WISHES ST LOUIS BROWNS 44.45" | | premium members only |
| Giannoulas, Ted | BB | Card | By Mail | (2) "THE CHICKEN" | | premium members only |
| Groskloss, Howdy | BB | Card | By Mail | BLACK SHARPIE PIRATES | | premium members only |
| Fletcher, Scott | BB | Card | By Mail | INDEX CARD BLUE SHARPIE "3:16" RANGERS WHITESOX | | premium members only |
| Franks, Herman | BB | Card | By Mail | BLUE SHARPIE DODGERS | | premium members only |
| Doerr, Bobby | BB | Card | By Mail | (9) INDEX CARDS REDSOX 5 BLUE SHARPIE, 4 BLUE INK, 1 BLACK INK | | premium members only |
| Boehmer, Len | BB | Index Card | By Mail | BLUE SHARPIE YANKEES REDS | | premium members only |
| Aust, Dennis | BB | Card | By Mail | index card "1965-66 cardinals | | premium members only |
| Allison, Dana | BB | Card | By Mail | 1991 Score in blue (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| Fowlkes, Alan | BB | Card | By Mail | 1983 Topps in blue (Giants) | | premium members only |
| Skinner, Joel | BB | Card | By Mail | 1988 Donruss in blue (Yankees) | | premium members only |
| Redding, Tim | BB | Card | By Mail | 2008 Topps Heritage in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Codiroli, Chris | BB | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps in blue (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| Cocanower, Jaime | BB | Card | By Mail | 1985 Fleer in blue (Brewers) | | premium members only |
| Cocanower, Jaime | BB | Card | By Mail | 1984 Fleer in blue (Brewers) | | premium members only |
| Allison, Dana | BB | Card | By Mail | 1991 Upperdeck in blue (Athletics) | | premium members only |
| Detwiler, Ross | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Heritage in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Roark, Tanner | BB | Card | In Person | 2015 Topps Heritage in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Cole, A.J. | BB | Card | In Person | 2015 Topps Heritage in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Ward, Thaddeus | BB | Card | In Person | 2023 Topps Heritage in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Schneider, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Topps Total in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Short, Rick | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Topps Heritage in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Hernandez, Livan | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Topps Total in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Armas, Tony Jr | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Topps Total in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Day, Zach | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Topps Total in blue (Nationals) | | premium members only |
| Reuschel, Rick | BB | Card | By Mail | 01 Topps American Pie #115 Cubs (blue sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Orosco, Jesse | BB | Card | Trade | 1984 Topps #396 New York Mets All-Star Card | | premium members only |
| Piatt, Adam | BB | Card | By Mail | 2002 MultiAd Sports #7 Sacramento River Cats | | premium members only |
| Piatt, Adam | BB | Card | By Mail | 2001 Post #28 Sacramento River Cats | | premium members only |
| Piatt, Adam | BB | Card | By Mail | 2003 Topps Total #14 A’s | | premium members only |
| Bolt, Skye | BB | Card | In Person | 2015 Panini Contenders Season Ticket No.86 (Blue Sharpie) North Carolina 5 Available | | premium members only |
| Bogusevic, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps 319 (Blue Sharpie) Astros | | premium members only |
| Bogusevic, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps 88 (Blue Sharpie) Astros | | premium members only |
| Bogusevic, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Rookie 209 (Blue Sharpie) Astros | | premium members only |
| Bogusevic, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Chrome Rookie 189 (Blue Sharpie) Astros | | premium members only |
| Bogusevic, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Bowman Draft Picks Rookie BDP113 (Blue Staedtler) Astros | | premium members only |
| Bogusevic, Brian | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks Rookie BDP113 (Blue Staedtler) Astros | | premium members only |
| Boggs, Mitch | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 PCL Top Prospect 23 of 36 (Blue Sharpie) Cardinals | | premium members only |
| Boggs, Mitch | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Bowman Draft Picks Rookie Card BDP10 (Blue Sharpie) Cardinals | | premium members only |
| Boggs, Brandon | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Nashville Sounds Team Card 8 of 36 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Bogany, Jarred | BB | Card | Trade | 2009 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP66 (Blue Staedtler) Cardinals | | premium members only |
| Boer, Madison | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Donruss Elite Extra Edition 64 (Blue Sharpie) Elizabethtown | | premium members only |
| Boer, Madison | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP85 (Blue Sharpie) 4 Available Twins | | premium members only |
| Boer, Madison | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects 1st Year Card BDPP85 (Blue Sharpie) Twins | | premium members only |
| Bochy, Bruce | BB | Card | By Mail | 1987 Topps 428 (Black Sharpie) Padres | | premium members only |
| Ishikawa, Travis | BB | Card | By Mail | 2006 fleer | | premium members only |
| Bleich, Jeremy | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Razor 31 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Blazek, Michael | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Texas League Top Prospect (Blue Sharpie) Springfield | | premium members only |
| Blass, Steve | BB | Card | By Mail | 1994 The Upper Deck Con 191 (Blue Sharpie) Pirates | | premium members only |
| Blass, Steve | BB | Card | By Mail | 1966 Topps 344 (Blue Pen Lightly Signed) Yankees | | premium members only |
| Blash, Jabari | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Topps Pro Debut 108 (Blue Sharpie) Clinton | | premium members only |
| Blash, Jabari | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps Pro Debut 119 (Blue Sharpie) Pulaski | | premium members only |
| Blash, Jabari | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP72 (Blue Sharpie) 4 Available Mariners | | premium members only |
| Blash, Jabari | BB | Card | In Person | 2012 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP72 (2 Blue Sharpie / 1 Blue Staedtler) Mariners | | premium members only |
| Blanton, Joe | BB | Card | In Person | 2006 Topps 143 (Blue Sharpie) A's | | premium members only |
| Blanton, Joe | BB | Card | In Person | 2004 PCL Top Prospects 6 of 36 (1 Blue Staedtler/1 Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Blank, Matt | BB | Card | In Person | 2002 Albuquerque Isotopes Team Card 7 of 36 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Blank, Matt | BB | Card | In Person | 2000 Bowman 181 (Blue Staedtler) Expos | | premium members only |
| Blank, Matt | BB | Card | In Person | 1999 Just 158 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Blank, Matt | BB | Card | In Person | 1999 Bowman Rookie 428 (Blue Staedtler) Expos | | premium members only |
| Blandino, Alex | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Topps Heritage Minor League Rookie 146 (Blue Sharpie) Blue Wahoos | | premium members only |
| Blandino, Alex | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Panini Prizm Pereninnial Draft Picks Draft Class No.27 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Blandino, Alex | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BCP119 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Reds | | premium members only |
| Blandino, Alex | BB | Card | In Person | 2014 Bowman Draft Picks DP25 (Blue Sharpie) Reds | | premium members only |
| Blandino, Alex | BB | Card | In Person | 2016 Bowman Prospects 1st Year Card BP119 (Blue Sharpie) 2 Available Reds | | premium members only |
| Blandino, Alex | BB | Card | In Person | 2015 Bowman Chrome Prospects 1st Year Card BCP242 (Blue Sharpie) Reds | | premium members only |
| Blanco, Andres | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Pacific Coast Top Prospects 6 of 36 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Blanco, Andres | BB | Card | In Person | 2004 Bowman Draft Picks 1st Year BDP151 (Blue Staedtler) Royals | | premium members only |
| Blakely, Darren | BB | Card | In Person | 1999 Team Best Rookie 4 (Blue Sharpie Bent in middle of Card) Angels | | premium members only |
| Blair, Willie | BB | Card | In Person | 1991 Topps 91 (Blue Sharpie) Blue Jays | | premium members only |
| Blair, Seth | BB | Card | In Person | 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition 97 (Blue Sharpie) Arizona State | | premium members only |
| Blair, Carson | BB | Card | Trade | 2008 Playoff Contenders Rookie 11 (Blue Sharpie) | | premium members only |
| Blair, Aaron | BB | Card | In Person | 2013 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects BDPP9 (Blue Sharpie) 3 Available Diamondbacks | | premium members only |
| Bladergroen, Ian | BB | Card | In Person | 2005 Bowman 1st Year Card 185 (Blue Staedtler) Red Sox | | premium members only |
| Blackmon, Charlie | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Tristar Prospect Plus 87 (Blue Staedtler) | | premium members only |
| Blackmon, Charlie | BB | Card | In Person | 2011 Topps US231 (Blue Sharpie) Rockies | | premium members only |
| Blackmon, Charlie | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Razor 59 (Blue Staedtler) Tri-City | | premium members only |
| Blackmon, Charlie | BB | Card | In Person | 2008 Playoff Contenders Rookie 12 (Blue Staedtler) Tri-City | | premium members only |
