| 282072 | Card | By Mail | 1988 Topps Glossy All Star | | premium members only |
| 282243 | Card | By Mail | 2000 Fleer Greats of the Game | | premium members only |
| 282432 | Card | By Mail | 2002 Donruss
| | premium members only |
| 282433 | Card | By Mail | 1986 Donruss | | premium members only |
| 282434 | Card | By Mail | 2007 Upper Deck | | premium members only |
| 282435 | Card | By Mail | 1988 Pacific | | premium members only |
| 269870 | Card | Trade | 2003 Topps Gallery Hall of Fame #39 - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 314126 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Upper Deck Past Time Pennants #9 Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 69334 | Card | By Mail | 1988 Pacific Legends #73 | | premium members only |
| 236670 | Card | By Mail | 2013 Allen & Ginter #19 | | premium members only |
| 17688 | Card | By Mail | 1988 Topps All-Star Set, blue, Red Sox |  | premium members only |
| 139741 | Card | Bought | 2001 Fleer Red Sox 100th, blue sharpie, "HOF86", Boston Red Sox, scan available upon request | | premium members only |
| 203564 | Card | Bought | 2003 Topps Gallery Referactor, blue sharpie, Boston Red Sox, scan available upon request | | premium members only |
| 217355 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Donruss Classics, blue sharpie, Boston Red Sox, scan available upon request | | premium members only |
| 67091 | Card | By Mail | 88 Pacific Legends #73 blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 140349 | Card | By Mail | 2001 Fleer Red Sox 100th Anniversary set, Yawkeys Heroes #YH1 | | premium members only |
| 140352 | Card | By Mail | 2007 Upper Deck Masterpieces # 59, | | premium members only |
| 140353 | Card | By Mail | 2007 Upper Deck Masterpieces # 59, with HOF | | premium members only |
| 140354 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Upper Deck Classics # 12, with HOF | | premium members only |
| 140355 | Card | By Mail | 2001 Upper Deck Legendary Cuts # 62, with HOF | | premium members only |
| 140356 | Card | By Mail | 2003 Upper Deck Play Ball #64, HOF | | premium members only |
| 145911 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Upper Deck Past Time Pennants signed in Blue | | premium members only |
| 254530 | Card | By Mail | Autographed 1994 Ted Williams trading card #3. (Boston Red Sox) | | premium members only |
| 254532 | Card | By Mail | Autographed 2000 Fleer Greats of the Game trading card #35. (Boston Red Sox) | | premium members only |
| 304842 | Card | By Mail | Autographed 2003 Donruss Team Heroes trading card #67. (Boston Red Sox) | | premium members only |
| 369097 | Card | Trade | Autographed 2001 Upper Deck Legendary Cuts trading card # 62. (Boston Red Sox) | | premium members only |
| 45705 | Card | By Mail | 2006 Allen & Ginter | | premium members only |
| 63538 | Card | By Mail | "signature card" - bat barrel - blue | | premium members only |
| 75295 | Card | By Mail | 2008 Upper Deck Goudey (#26) - blue sharpie (x2) | | premium members only |
| 77260 | Card | By Mail | 2006 Fleer Greats of the Game (#13) - black sharpie | | premium members only |
| 300168 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Upper Deck Classics 12;
2010 Topps Triple Threads 56 | | premium members only |
| 252017 | Card | By Mail | 1950 Bowman #43, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 252018 | Card | By Mail | 1986 Donruss Highlights #32, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 252019 | Card | By Mail | 2002 Donruss Diamond Kings #134, blue sharpie insc. "HOF 1986" - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 252020 | Card | By Mail | 2005 Upper Deck Classics #12, blue sharpie insc. "HOF 86" - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 252021 | Card | By Mail | 2013 Topps Allen & Ginter #19, blue sharpie - Red Sox | | premium members only |
| 161004 | Card | By Mail | 2000 Fleer Greats of the Game (Red Sox) | | premium members only |
| 161005 | Card | By Mail | 2003 Sweet Spot Classics (Red Sox) | | premium members only |
| 356101 | Card | By Mail | Bobby Doerr, 1990 Pacific Baseball Legends #21, Red Sox, signed in blue, HOF, DECEASED | | premium members only |
| 140078 | Card | By Mail | 1989 Pacific. Pic upon request. | | premium members only |
| 303061 | Card | By Mail | 2003 UD SP "Legendary Cuts 140/275** Blue Steadtler RED SOX | | premium members only |
| 166220 | Card | By Mail | 92 Action Packed signed in blue sharpie. Donruss Gallery of Stars signed in blue sharpie. Happy to send scans. | | premium members only |
| 328035 | Card | Trade | '06 Fleer Greats of the Game #13 Boston Red Sox signed in blue | | premium members only |
| 289725 | Card | By Mail | 2007 UD Masterpieces blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 292294 | Card | By Mail | 1988 Pacific Baseball Legends in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 383903 | Card | Bought | 2013 Topps Allen & Ginter - Blue Sharpie | | premium members only |
| 285564 | Card | By Mail | 2006 A&G Allen Ginter, 1998 pacific | | premium members only |
| 289812 | Index Card | By Mail | blue, unlined | | premium members only |
| 56726 | Index Card | By Mail | Index card signed in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 272004 | Index Card | By Mail | unlined side | | premium members only |
| 25470 | Index Card | By Mail | blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 26007 | Index Card | By Mail | Autographed index card. | | premium members only |
| 21437 | Index Card | By Mail | Unlined index card signed in blue ink | | premium members only |
| 264023 | Index Card | By Mail | Hall of Fame; Boston Red Sox (1937–1944, 1946–1951) | | premium members only |
| 382065 | Index Card | By Mail | (9) INDEX CARDS REDSOX 5 BLUE SHARPIE, 4 BLUE INK, 1 BLACK INK | | premium members only |
| 82894 | Photo | By Mail | Autographed 4x6 black/white photo signed in thin black sharpie with HOF 1986 Inscription. | | premium members only |
| 204626 | HOF Postcard | Trade | Certified - Yellow and Brown Hall of Fame Plaque - PSA | | premium members only |
| 120580 | HOF Postcard | By Mail | Signed in black sharpie by Mr. Doerr. | | premium members only |
| 204631 | Perez Steele | By Mail | Certified - 1987 Perez Steele HOF #194 PSA DNA | | premium members only |
