| 282278 | Card | By Mail | 1964 Topps | | premium members only |
| 217398 | Card | Trade | 2004 Upper Deck Legends Timeless Teams, blue sharpie, New York Yankees, scan available upon request | | premium members only |
| 310341 | Card | By Mail | 1991 Crown, blue sharpie, Baltimore Orioles, scan available upon request, pictured with Kansas City Royals | | premium members only |
| 310342 | Card | By Mail | Custom Orioles Card, blue sharpie, Baltimore Orioles, scan available upon request | | premium members only |
| 298210 | Card | Trade | Autographed 1981 Fleer trading card #85. (New York Yankees) |  | premium members only |
| 385426 | Card | By Mail | 1980 TOPPS #225 YANKEES IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 385428 | Card | By Mail | 1982 TOPPS #538 YANKEES IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 385429 | Card | By Mail | 1981 TOPPS #724 YANKEES IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 385431 | Card | By Mail | 1971 TOPPS #321 ROYALS IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 385432 | Card | By Mail | 1987 TOPPS #168 YANKEES IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 385433 | Card | By Mail | 1990 TOPPS TRADED #96T REDS IN BLUE SHARPIE ADDED 90 WSC | | premium members only |
| 385434 | Card | By Mail | 1972 TOPPS #491 ROYALS IN BLUE SHARPIE | | premium members only |
| 385435 | Card | By Mail | 1981 DONRUSS #109 YANKEES IN BLUE SHARPIE ADDED "#14" | | premium members only |
| 267685 | Card | Bought | 1972 Topps # 580 - black pen | | premium members only |
| 267791 | Card | Bought | 1982 Donruss # 135 - blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 247432 | Card | In Person | 1990 Pacific Legends #99, black sharpie | | premium members only |
| 280310 | Card | In Person | 1974 Topps card signed in blue sharpie | | premium members only |
| 333779 | Card | Bought | 1987 Topps #168 Black Sharpie YANKEES | | premium members only |
| 201950 | Card | By Mail | 1970 Topps #321 | | premium members only |
| 359915 | Card | By Mail | 1964 RC in Blue Sharpie
1969 RC in Blue Sharpie | | premium members only |
| 285482 | Card | By Mail | 1968 topps rookie stars, 2007 allen & ginter A&G | | premium members only |
| 304835 | Card | By Mail | 1982 Fleer #48 Light Smudge Blue | | premium members only |
| 315253 | Card | By Mail | 1984 Topps, 1986 Topps Traded (Yankees), 1991 Topps (Reds), 2002 Topps Chrome (Mariners), 2005 Topps (Devil Rays)- signed in blue. | | premium members only |
| 115548 | Index Card | Trade | 4.25 X 2.75 creme stationary mounted on white 3 X 5 in black bic. | | premium members only |
